سؤال وجواب

Is it permissible to make an AI video, for example with ChatGPT, in which a person speaks who does not exist in reality?

Question سؤال

Answer جواب

This is an English translation of the Bangla original. Read the original (Bangla)

First we need to discuss the ruling on making digital videos. In the view of a large section of contemporary scholars, making digital videos of living beings is not permissible, just like printed pictures. They take as evidence the hadith about the gravity of making images. The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:

إِنَّ أَشَدَّ النَّاسِ عَذَابًا عِنْدَ الله يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ المصُوِّرُونَ.

Meaning: “Indeed, the most severely punished people on the Day of Resurrection will be those who make images.” (Bukhari, hadith 5606; Muslim, hadith 2109)

Another group of scholars holds that digital pictures or videos are permissible as long as they are not printed, do not show women, and do not show anything else that is haram.

As for the matter in the question, scholars have permitted making this kind of AI video on three conditions:

One: the video must not contain anything contrary to Islamic teachings or the Shariah.

Two: the video must not use music or musical instruments.

Three: the video must not show women without hijab. (Fiqh al-Buyu’: 1/325)

Note that the view permitting AI videos under conditions is not unanimous; it is the view of a number of scholars in the Arab world and the subcontinent. Those who hold that making digital pictures or videos is always impermissible also hold that making AI videos is impermissible. So although there is room to take the permissive view, subject to the conditions above, in a case of genuine need, where there is no need the first view, that it is impermissible, is to be preferred.

“وأما فعل التصوير فهو غير جائز مطلقا لأنه مضاهاة لخلق الله تعالى”.

(كتاب الصلاة، باب ما يفسد الصلاة وما يكره فيها، 650/1، ط: سعيد)

فقه البیوع: (325/1، ط: مكتبة دار العلوم كراتشي)‏
ولكن معظم استعمال التلفزيون في عصرنا في برامج لا يخلو من محظور شرعي، ‏و عامة المشترين يشترونه لهذه الأغراض المحظورة من مشاهدة الأفلام والبرامج ‏الممنوعة، و إن كان هناك من لا يقصد به ذلك‎.‎‏ فبما أن استعماله في مباح ‏ممكن، فلا نحكم بالكراهة التحريمية في بيعه مطلقا، إلا إذا تعين بيعه لمحظور، ‏ولكن نظرا إلى معظم استعماله لا يخلو من كراهة تنزيهية‎.‎‏ وعلى هذا، فينبغي ‏أن يتحوط المسلم في اتخاذ تجارته مهنة في الحالة الراهنة، إلا إذا هيأ الله سبحانه ‏جوا يتمحض أو يكثر فيه استعماله المباح، والله سبحانه و تعالى أعلم

Answered by:
Mufti Ziaur Rahman
Ambarkhana, Sylhet


فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ

If you don't know, ask

Send us your question. Scholars will answer in the light of the Quran and Sunnah, and the answer will be published in the Q&A section.