سؤال وجواب

For a valid qurbani, does the location of the person offering it count, or the location of the animal?

Question سؤال

Answer جواب

This is an English translation of the Bangla original. Read the original (Bangla)

Before discussing the main issue, we need to understand how the obligation of qurbani was established. Look at the hadith from the blessed tongue of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, in which the Prophet ﷺ speaks of the obligation of qurbani: مَنْ وَجَدَ سَعَةً فَلَمْ يُضَحِّ فَلَا يَقْرَبَنَّ مُصَلَّانَا Meaning: “Whoever has the means and does not offer qurbani, let him not come near our place of prayer.” (Musnad Ahmad, Mustadrak al-Hakim)

All the jurists agree that “having the means” here means having the means during the days of qurbani. So qurbani becomes wajib on whoever attains financial sufficiency during those days.

Now let us come to our main topic.
What we understand from the jurists about a valid qurbani is this: for the date, the location of the person offering it counts, and for the time, the location of the animal counts. The reason is that qurbani becomes wajib on a person when, between true dawn on 10 Dhul Hijjah and sunset on 12 Dhul Hijjah, he is financially able by the Shariah standard. Once qurbani has become wajib on him, we look at where the animal is. If it is in a town, the qurbani must be made after the Eid prayer on the day of Eid al-Adha. If it is in a village (meaning a remote area where neither Eid nor Jumu’ah prayers are held and which has little connection to a town), the qurbani is valid right after true dawn. As it says in al-Hidayah: ثم المعتبر فی ذالک مکان الاضحية That is, the location of the animal is what counts.

For a valid qurbani, the place where it is made counts. That is, where the animal is slaughtered, qurbani is valid until sunset on 12 Dhul Hijjah there. So if, in the country where an expatriate lives, the days of qurbani have passed and 13 Dhul Hijjah has arrived, the qurbani is still valid if in his home country, where the qurbani is being made, it is the 11th or 12th of Dhul Hijjah. For where the qurbani is being performed, the days of nahr are still running. ويعتبر مكان المذبوح لا مكان المالك… ولوكان هو في مصر وقت الأضحية وأهله في مصر آخر فكتب إلي الأهل وأمرهم بالتضحية في ظاهر الرواية يعتبر مكان الأضحة. (خانية زكريا: ٣/٢٤٣) والمعتبر مكان الأضحية لا مكان المضحي. (البحر الرائق: ٨/٣١٧)

From the above it is clear that if the date in one country is ahead, and a citizen of that country appoints someone in a country where the date is behind to make the qurbani on his behalf, a qurbani made before true dawn on 10 Dhul Hijjah in the country that is behind is not valid, because the time for qurbani has not yet come there. What counts here is the place where the qurbani is made: since its time has not come in that place, a qurbani made before the set time is not valid. For example, someone in England appoints someone in Bangladesh as his agent.

On the other hand, if someone in a country whose date is behind appoints someone in a country whose date is ahead to make his qurbani, then a qurbani made for him (through the agent) in the country that is ahead, before true dawn on 10 Dhul Hijjah arrives in his own country, is not valid, because qurbani has not yet become wajib on him. For example, someone in Bangladesh appoints someone in England to make his qurbani. Here, what counts is the location of the person offering it.

To conclude: qurbani is an act of worship full of love from Allah, and a special blessing for us. Through sacrificing this animal we can strive to sacrifice our own ego, and lay the foundation for guiding ourselves on the path of taqwa. May Allah grant us all the ability to perform qurbani according to the Shariah. Amin.


فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ

If you don't know, ask

Send us your question. Scholars will answer in the light of the Quran and Sunnah, and the answer will be published in the Q&A section.