This is an English translation of the Bangla original. Read the original (Bangla)
Reviewing the evidence of the Quran and hadith on dhikr, we understand that collective loud dhikr cannot be emphasised across the board, nor can collective dhikr be called bid’ah across the board. Rather, the Noble Quran gives preference to quiet dhikr. It says:
وَاذْكُرْ رَبَّكَ فِي نَفْسِكَ تَضَرُّعًا وَخِيفَةً وَدُونَ الْجَهْرِ مِنَ الْقَوْلِ بِالْغُدُوِّ وَالْآَصَالِ وَلَا تَكُنْ مِنَ الْغَافِلِينَ
Meaning: “And remember your Lord within yourself, humbly and in awe, without raising your voice, morning and evening, and do not be among the heedless.” (Surah al-A’raf: 205)
This verse states very briefly several ways of remembering Allah, among them quiet dhikr. Remembering Allah abundantly is a deed of great reward and virtue. But the Shariah does not make any particular method or tariqah of dhikr compulsory. So no one may be pressured into sitting in a gathering of collective dhikr, and no one who does not join may be looked down upon.
Allah the Exalted says: يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا اذْكُرُوا اللَّهَ ذِكْرًا كَثِيرًا Meaning: “O you who believe, remember Allah abundantly.” (Surah al-Ahzab: 41)
In a hadith qudsi Allah the Exalted says: أَنَا عِنْدَ ظَنِّ عَبْدِي بِي، وَأَنَا مَعَهُ إِذَا ذَكَرَنِي، فَإِنْ ذَكَرَنِي فِي نَفْسِهِ ذَكَرْتُهُ فِي نَفْسِي، وَإِنْ ذَكَرَنِي فِي مَلَأٍ ذَكَرْتُهُ فِي مَلَأٍ خَيْرٍ مِنْهُمْ. Meaning: “I am as My servant thinks of Me, and I am with him when he remembers Me. If he remembers Me within himself, I remember him within Myself; and if he remembers Me in a gathering, I remember him in a gathering better than theirs.” (Bukhari: 7405; Muslim: 2675)
Abu Musa al-Ash’ari (ra) reported: We were with the Messenger of Allah ﷺ on a campaign. Each time we climbed a height or went down into a valley, we would raise our voices with takbir. The Messenger of Allah ﷺ came to us and said:
يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ، أرْبعُوا عَلَى أَنْفُسِكُمْ؛ فإنَّكم لَا تَدْعُونَ أَصَمَّ وَلَا غَائِبًا، إِنَّهُ مَعَكُمْ، إِنَّهُ سَمِيعٌ قَرِيبٌ.
Meaning: “O people, be gentle with yourselves. You are not calling one who is deaf or absent. He is with you; He is All-Hearing, Near.” (Bukhari: 9229; Muslim: 2704)
Another hadith also says:
خَيْرُ الذِّكْرِ الْخَفِيُّ “The best dhikr is the silent one.” (Ahmad, Ibn Hibban)
However, if an accomplished saint who fully follows the Shariah holds a gathering of dhikr somewhere for the islah and tarbiyah of his disciples, where it does not disturb the worship of others and no new method is invented, then it is permissible and there is no harm in it. But if some unreliable so-called pir holds a customary dhikr gathering in which the Shariah is not observed, in which those who do not take part are belittled, mocked or pressured, or which disturbs the worship of others, then holding such a dhikr gathering is not permissible at all.
Ibn Mas’ud (ra) sternly forbade everyone at one such dhikr gathering that ignored the Shariah, and drove them out of the mosque. (Shami: 9/570)
عن ابن مسعود رضى الله عنه أنه أخرج جماعة من المسجد يهللون ويصلون على النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم جهرا وقال لهم: ما أراكم إلا مبتدعين الخ، هل يكره رفع الصوت بالذكر والدعاء؟ قيل نعم! (شامى زكريا: ٩/٥٧٠) It is reported from Ibn Abbas (ra) that in the time of the Messenger ﷺ it was the practice to make dhikr aloud when people turned away after finishing the fard prayer. (Muslim: 1/217; Abu Dawud: 1/144) إن أبا معبد مولى ابن عباس أخبره أن رفع الصوت للذكر حين ينصرف الناس من المكتوبة كان ذالك على عهد رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم. وأن ابن عباس رضى الله عنهما قال: كنت أعلم إذا انصرفوا بذالك وأسمعه. (رواه مسلم: ١/٢١٧ و أبو داود: ١/١٤٤)
From the two kinds of report above it is clear that there is evidence on both sides: some in favour of collective dhikr and some against. So gatherings of collective dhikr should be controlled, occasional, restrained, and suited to the place, time and people.
So, in the light of all this evidence, the researched view of the scholars is that in dhikr both ways, jali and khafi, aloud or quietly, are permissible. Which is better or less good in a given situation is decided in the light of that situation. But for loud dhikr several conditions deserve special attention:
1. Not to regard this form of dhikr as the sole aim and the principal worship, but to take it as a means of reaching the goal and of training the self.
2. Not to rebuke, belittle or speak ill of anyone who does not take part in the dhikr gathering.
3. Since collective loud dhikr in a mosque or an open place carries a strong risk that people will come to see it as obligatory and fundamental worship, dhikr gatherings may be held at home or in some particular place, not in open places.
4. Not to make loud dhikr in a mosque or in any place where it causes, or may cause, trouble to worshippers or the public.
5. Not to regard arranging food at the dhikr gathering as necessary, nor to collect contributions openly from everyone for it.
6. That the dhikr not be done for riya, to be seen by people.
With these points in mind, loud dhikr is permissible, whether collectively in a circle or in rows. But dhikr alone and quietly is better; this is what we understand from the Quran, the hadith and the statements of the jurists. Moreover, jumping about and shouting in the name of dhikr is not established by the sunnah, and doing such things willingly and knowingly is not permitted.
Note: some of our brothers strongly oppose collective dhikr, give blanket fatwas that it is bid’ah and declare it haram. Apparently they oppose it because the dhikr is “collective” and “aloud”. First, there is no room for a blanket fatwa that collective dhikr is bid’ah or haram, since there is evidence on both sides, as discussed above. In particular circumstances it may become impermissible, but not always.
Sadly, though, those who oppose collective and loud dhikr across the board are often seen to be very neglectful of dhikr alone and in silence too. Yet even if there is discussion about collective and loud dhikr, there is no disagreement about dhikr alone. If collective dhikr is opposed in order to follow the way of the Messenger, then, following the way of the Messenger, one’s tongue should always be busy with dhikr. For the hadith says: كَانَ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ ، يَذْكُرُ اللَّهَ عَلَى كُلِّ أَحْيَانِهِ. (رواه مسلم: ٣٧٣) “The Noble Prophet ﷺ was occupied in the remembrance of Allah at all times.” (Muslim: 373)
So before opposing it, I request a little reckoning with one’s conscience: why do I oppose collective dhikr? Is my intention good, or do I oppose it only because I am on the opposing side? How much of the time is my tongue busy with the remembrance of Allah? How much dhikr do I make every day? I request a little reckoning with one’s heart. May Allah grant us the good fortune of remembering Him at all times. Amin.
References:
1. The Quran
2. Sahih al-Bukhari,
3. Sahih Muslim,
4. Sunan Abi Dawud,
5. Mishkat al-Masabih,
6. Radd al-Muhtar,
7. Imdad al-Fatawa,
8. Aziz al-Fatawa,
9. Fatawa Usmani,
10. Kitab al-Nawazil.
Writer:
Imam and Khatib, Ambarkhana Jame Masjid, Sylhet.
Director, Sianah Trust and Islamic Fiqh Institute



